Reviews
4.9 stars · 264 households.
The pattern below: renewals re-shopped instead of shrugged at, claims advocated, and math honest enough to occasionally cost us a sale.
Ratings summary and individual reviews
264 VERIFIED REVIEWS
Reviews come from active households and businesses. We publish the four-star ones too — insuring a 16-year-old driver is expensive everywhere, and pretending otherwise would be an exclusion buried in fine print.
"My home renewal jumped 38% and my old agent said 'that's the market.' Shieldrow re-shopped it: same coverage, better roof endorsement, $612 less per year."
"The review found our house was insured for $180k less than it would cost to rebuild — set years ago and never updated. Fixing THAT mattered more than any discount. They found a discount anyway."
"New LLC, no idea what a BOP was. Thirty minutes later I had coverage explained in shop-owner English, a certificate for my landlord same day, and a bill smaller than my guess by half."
"Hail claim on our roof. Nora told us honestly it WAS worth filing, then stayed on the adjuster until the depreciation math came out right. Someone fluent in insurance on OUR side changed everything."
"Teen driver added: still expensive (physics and actuaries agree), but Shieldrow shopped nine carriers and beat our old quote by $71/mo. Four stars only because insurance for a 16-year-old exists at all."
"They told me NOT to file a claim once — the math would have cost me more in surcharges than the repair. An agency that occasionally talks you out of using insurance is an agency you keep for decades."
Bring us the renewal that scared you.
Thirty minutes, twelve-plus carriers, a written summary — and about two-thirds of renewal-shock reviews find real money.